Menu

UW001
Effects of land cover, topography, and built structure on seasonal water quality at multiple spatial scales in Clark County, WA and the metropolitan area of Portland, OR

AUTHOR: Heejun Chang, Bethany Pratt
CREATOR(S): Heejun Chang
PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATOR(S): Heejun Chang
ORIGINATOR(S): Heejun Chang
DATA SET CONTACT PERSON: Heejun Chang
METADATA CREATION DATE:
18 Dec 2012
MOST RECENT METADATA REVIEW DATE:
16 Feb 2013
KEYWORDS:
Human-natural systems, Disturbance, water chemistry, topography, water quality, resource management, disturbance, landscape change, watersheds, human natural systems
PURPOSE:
This study was developed as part of the interdisciplinary PV-ULTRA-Ex project to investigate the complex interactions and feedback among land development, disturbance and water quality in the Portland/Vancouver metropolitan area. This particular study explores the relationship between landscape variables and water quality in the Portland, Oregon and Clark County, Washington area to examine if the season or scale of analysis matters in determining what land cover has the most influence on water quality.The study additionally compares the predictive power of GWR, which incorporates spatial autocorrelation, to a global OLS regression model.
METHODS:
Experimental Design - UW001:
Description:

We collected water quality data from several government agencies, and downloaded spatial stream data from the US Geological Survey (USGS) National Hydrography Dataset [1]. Washington water quality data was collected from Washington Department of Ecology [2], as well as Clark County Environmental Services [3]. The Portland Bureau of Environmental Services has been collecting monthly stream data at select sites consistently since 1998–2010. Twenty-one sites from Portland and 30 sites from Clark County were selected based on the available sample dates, parameters, and watershed characteristics. Each government agency collected data based on their sampling methods and quality control on USEPA standards. Seven water quality parameters were chosen based on its importance to human and aquatic life in both Portland and Vancouver study sites. Nitrogen nitrate NO3+–N (NN) and total phosphorus (TP) are generally considered to be direct measures of human activity in an area, as fertilizers, vehicle emissions, and impervious surfaces increase the amount of NN and TP in their respective natural cycles [4]. Total solids (TS) can be used as a quantitative measure of aesthetics as suspended sediments in streams make the water appear cloudy. This study also used conductivity (EC), dissolved oxygen (DO), pH, and water temperature (Temp). These measurements are associated with predicting algae bloom likelihood and habitat quality for fish and other aquatic animals. In order to account for the seasonal variation in stream flows, the data were split into wet (November–April) and dry (May–October) seasons. The seasonal data were aggregated to a geometric mean for the entire period. The geometric mean was used because it is a slightly more conservative estimate of aggregated water quality parameters than an arithmetic mean. It is also more appropriate to use a geometric mean when data are not normally distributed, which was the case for two parameters. The standard deviation of slope, derived here from a 10 m digital elevation model, has been used in past studies as a measure of topography complexity where the study area is relatively flat, which is the case in many of the urban watersheds [5]. The 2006 US National Land Cover Dataset was used to categorize percent urban, forest, agriculture, and wetlands in each area, with areas of less than 0.1% not included for analysis. Structural variables include single family residential (SFR) taxlots and street density. These spatial data allowed researchers a finer scale with which to examine land development within the study area. The percent area of SFR provided a measure of residential housing impact. Average building age of SFR homes built before 2010 was used as a measure of historical development. Street density provides a measure of habitat fragmentation as well as impervious surfaces. We used the 2010 taxlot and streets datasets produced by Clark County and the Portland Metropolitan Authority. In order to determine the association between landscape variables and water quality at each monitoring site, this study uses sectioned watersheds and riparian buffers. These sectioned zones limit the area associated with the sample site to the next site immediately upstream. The riparian buffer was used to determine if the immediate environment surrounding the stream has a stronger relationship than the entire area. Watersheds were delineated from the 51 sample sites using the 10 m DEM in ArcGIS v10.0, while the riparian areas were created by buffering the streams 100 m. The downstream watersheds and riparian areas were clipped to the upstream watershed, where applicable, to create sectioned watersheds and buffers. The area of SFR was normalized to a percent coverage of the area, and the streets layer was normalized to length (m)/(1000) area (m2). SFR house age was averaged from SFR taxlots present in the sectioned area. Land cover and topographic variables were calculated using the Spatial Analyst tools in ArcGIS.

Citation: [1] United States Geologic Survey (USGS), National Hydrography Dataset, 2011, http://nhd.usgs.gov/. [2] Washington Department of Ecology (WADE), Current Washington State Water Quality Assessment, 2008 (Last accessed 25 May 2011) http://www.ecy.wa.gov/programs/wq/303d/2008/index.html. [3] WADE, Environmental Information Management System, 2011 (last accessed 21.05.11) http://www.ecy.wa.gov/eim/. [4] A.L. Heathwaite, Multiple stressors on water availability at global to catchment scales: understanding human impact on nutrient cycles to protect water quality and water availability in the long term, Freshw. Biol. 55 (2010) 241–257. [5] L. Sliva, D.D. Williams, Buffer zone versus whole catchment approaches to studying land use impact on river water quality, Water Res. 35 (2001) 3462–3472.
Statistics - UW001:
Description: All variables were tested for a normal distribution using the onesample Kolmogorov–Smirnov test, which tests for normality by examining the observed and theoretical distributions and determining if the difference between them is significant [6]. Of the seven seasonal water quality parameters, wet and dry for each (total 14), three were found to be skewed. The dry season NN and DO were transformed exponentially and logarithmically, respectively, while a single record was removed from the dry season EC to resolve skewness. Of the independent variables, normalization was achieved by removing records less than 10% and performing log transformations. Soil type A was removed entirely because it was present in only two watersheds and one buffer area. Multivariate OLS regression and GWR models were developed to examine the relationship between the independent variables and the water quality parameters. Multivariate analysis filters out the significant variables across the landscape [7,8]. To find the independent variables with the strongest correlation with the water parameters, stepwise multiple linear regression (SMLR) was run in PASW Statistics 17. With seven water quality parameters, two seasons, and two scales of analysis, 28 OLS models were generated. SMLR models run using only those independent variables identified as significant at the 95% confidence level. These variables were then used to run GWR and OLS regressions in ArcMap. An advantage of running an OLS regression in ArcMap is the output from the process includes the residual for each site, allowing the researcher to more easily test the residuals for spatial autocorrelation. We used Global Moran’s I for the residuals of both OLS and GWR models to test spatial dependence.
Citation: [6] R.A. Olea, V. Pawlowsky-Glahn, Kolmogorov–Smirnov test for spatially correlated data, Stoch. Environ. Res. Risk Assess. 23 (2009) 749–757. [7] J.J. Rothwell, N.B. Dise, K.G. Taylor, T.E.H. Allott, P. Scholefield, H. Davies, C. Neal, Predicting river water quality across North West England using catchment characteristics, J. Hydrol. 395 (2010) 153–162. [8] X.L. Wang, J.Y. Han, L.G. Xu, Q. Zhang, Spatial and seasonal variations of the contamination within water body of the Grand Canal, China, Environ. Pollut. 158 (2010) 1513–1520.
SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION:
Collected from Portland Bureau of Environmental Services and Clark County Environmental Services’ long-term monitoring program.
SITE DESCRIPTION:
Balch Creek, Columbia Slough, Fanno Creek, Johnson Creek, Kelley Creeks, Tryon Creeks, Westside Streams, Willamette River
TAXONOMIC SYSTEM:
None
GEOGRAPHIC EXTENT:
Portland metropolitan area of Oregon and Clark County, Washington
MEASUREMENT FREQUENCY:
monthly
PROGRESS DESCRIPTION:
Complete
UPDATE FREQUENCY DESCRIPTION:
notPlanned
CURRENTNESS REFERENCE:
Observed
RELATED MATERIAL:
B. Pratt, H. Chang. Effects of land cover, topography, and built structure on seasonal water quality at multiple spatial scales, J. Hazard. Mater. 209– 210 (2012) 48– 58.